Casey Key is one of Sarasota County’s most distinctive luxury waterfront communities. This narrow barrier island is bordered by the Gulf of Mexico on the west and Little Sarasota Bay on the east, creating an exceptionally private coastal setting.
Follow active listings, pending sales, and homes sold within the past six months in Casey Key. The report updates automatically as MLS data changes.
Casey Key real estate consists primarily of single-family homes, ranging from classic beach cottages and architecturally significant residences to newly constructed waterfront estates. Some properties extend from the Gulf to the bay, providing both private beach frontage and boating access.
Casey Key offers a peaceful, low-density environment with very little commercial development. The island appeals to buyers who value privacy, natural surroundings, boating and direct access to the Gulf Coast.
Residents are conveniently located near the restaurants, shopping and services of Nokomis, Osprey and Venice. Downtown Sarasota and Siesta Key are also within easy driving distance.
Nearby destinations include:
Select properties extend across the island from the Gulf of Mexico to Little Sarasota Bay. These rare residences may provide private beach frontage on one side and a boat dock on the other.
Gulf-front properties offer direct beach access, panoramic water views and spectacular sunsets. Value is influenced by lot size, elevation, shoreline condition, construction quality and the home’s position along the island.
Homes along the bay may include docks, boat lifts and access to the Intracoastal Waterway. Buyers should verify water depth, bridge clearance and the route to the Gulf for their specific vessel.
Casey Key features a diverse collection of architectural styles. Smaller Old Florida cottages sit alongside contemporary homes and expansive private estates designed around water views and outdoor living.
Purchasing on a barrier island requires careful evaluation. We help buyers investigate important considerations, including:
Because Casey Key properties are highly individual, traditional price-per-square-foot comparisons may not tell the entire story. Lot characteristics, water frontage, elevation, privacy, views and boating access can significantly affect value.
Rental regulations can depend on the property’s location, zoning, deed restrictions and applicable Sarasota County requirements. Buyers considering rental income should verify the rules for the specific address before purchasing.
Insurance and renovation requirements can also vary substantially between older coastal homes and newer elevated construction.
As Coldwell Banker Broker Associates, Scott and Jan Langa have completed more than 400 real estate transactions throughout Sarasota County and the surrounding barrier islands.
We help buyers analyze waterfront properties, investigate insurance and permitting considerations, evaluate boating access and negotiate favorable terms.
Whether you are searching for a Gulf-front estate, Gulf-to-bay property, boating residence or private coastal retreat, Team Langa will guide you from the initial search through inspections, closing and beyond.
Spanning nearly an acre from the Gulf of Mexico to Blackburn Bay, this one-of-a-kind Casey Key residence pairs 140 feet of private Gulf frontage with 130 feet of protecte...
Virtually Staged. Imagine the possibilities of Gulf-to-Bay living on Casey Key, where deeded private beach access, deep-water boating and a resort-style bayfront setting ...
At the water’s edge of Sandspur Lane sits one of Casey Key’s best-kept secrets: a stunning estate offering unmatched privacy, tranquility, protected waterfront, and bespo...
A rare Gulf-to-Bay opportunity on Casey Key, where nearly an acre of land stretches from the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico to the protected waters of the bay. Wi...
A rare Gulf-to-Bay opportunity on Casey Key, where nearly an acre of land stretches from the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico to the protected waters of the bay. Wi...
At the northernmost point of Casey Key, where the Gulf meets the tranquil waters of Little Sarasota and Blackburn Bay, an extraordinary private estate unfolds between two...
Welcome to your private coastal retreat on the barrier island of Casey Key. Nestled along charming Sandspur Lane, this exceptional home is ideally positioned between the ...
Pre-Construction. To be built. An extraordinary opportunity on Casey Key, set across 1.37 private acres with an exceptional 300 feet of deep-water bay frontage, one of th...
Rare Gulf-front offering with 100 feet of private sandy beach on approximately 0.75 acres, delivering exceptional privacy on one of Casey Key’s most coveted stretches. Wi...
Experience true Florida coastal living in this impeccably maintained Key West–style home on Casey Key, offering the rare and coveted Gulf-to-Bay lifestyle. Thoughtfully d...
Virtually Staged. Vintage Waterfront Cottage on Casey Key. Quietly set on Casey Cove Drive, a private cul-de-sac just off Casey Key Road, this refreshed vintage cottage...
Gulf Front, private beach. This sun-drenched Florida villa captures the character of a Mexican hacienda with the ease of tropical coastal living. Smooth stucco exteriors...
IT'S ALWAYS ALL ABOUT THE LOCATION! Casey Key is a very private narrow barrier island located just North of Venice FL and South of Siesta Key; it separates the intracosta...
One of the last remaining vacant bayfront parcels on exclusive Casey Key. This nearly one-acre property offers approximately 130 feet of serene bay frontage, an ideal can...
:format(webp):quality(80)/u.realgeeks.media/srqhousehunters/Stacked_Logo.jpg){kind=logo}
